Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michelle Shaw's avatar

I think it is incorrect to lay at the door of MAiD the deficits in our social support programs that it exposes.

Opponents to MAiD yammer on incessantly about “natural death” - I got to watch my mother die that “natural death” this past summer - it was by no means peaceful, or easy - her last months were filled with the infirmities of a failing body, and an accelerating dementia that made it impossible for her to understand what was happening. MAiD was not an option in her case for a number of reasons, but anyone talking about “natural death” has no idea what the hell they are talking about.

The obvious problems with our supports for disability and those who need those supports are being made clear by the discussion of people accessing MAiD because those supports are so woefully inadequate. That isn’t the fault of MAiD - it is the fault of governments who find it much safer to talk about “tax cuts”, and “job creation” rather than actually funding support programs properly.

MAiD certainly raises a myriad of complex moral and ethical issues for medical practitioners that we should not ignore. Those are complex discussions that exist within the practice of medicine, and deserve to be carefully scrutinized through an appropriate ethical lens. However, difficult ethical problems are seldom resolved adequately with absolutist answers. Just as with abortion, MAiD needs to become the purview of the doctor and the patient working together to arrive at an ethical decision. Lawmakers attempting to draw out ethical boundaries inevitably creates a series of pernicious legal problems that are next to impossible to address with the relatively blunt language of law.

When I see these columns, I am reminded of a protest over cuts to AISH that Klein enacted where Klein quipped of protestors “they don’t look very disabled to me”. The cruelty of the far right (call them neoliberal or neoconservative if you wish) is the underlying problem, not MAiD.

Expand full comment
Megan Quaglia Linton's avatar

Jeremy,

This was such a beautiful piece. Thanks for your humility in your change of perspective.

Solidarity,

ML

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts