For the past two years, landowner advocates who participated in consultations on Alberta’s strategy to reduce the thousands of inactive oil and gas wells across the province have warned that the entire process was skewed against them and towards industry.
Documents newly obtained through access to information confirm the extent to which that was the case, with the government consulting nine industry groups for every landowner advocacy group or municipal government body.
The industry groups engaged in consultations include companies that owe the government money for paying their delinquent surface lease payments to landowners and a well-sealing company whose former CEO is the person in charge of the strategy.
The so-called Mature Asset Strategy (MAS), overseen by Premier Danielle Smith’s special advisor David Yager, is intended to accelerate the cleanup of the province’s 77,354 inactive wells, stimulate production for low-producing shallow gas wells, increase the value of natural gas, and address companies’ non-payment of municipal property taxes and leases to landowners.
Beginning in August 2024, Yager and Ministry of Energy and Minerals officials engaged in consultations to inform the strategy’s final report through six working groups, each focused on a different aspect of the strategy.
Phillip Meintzer of the Coalition for Responsible Energy obtained the list of people who participated in each working group through ATI, which he provided to The Orchard.
He said he filed the ATI request “because there was no publicly disclosed information about what companies or industry groups were invited to participate in the MAS process.”
“We had heard from landowner representatives and [Rural Municipalities of Alberta] reps who participated in the MAS that it was an industry dominated process,” said Meintzer, “but we wanted to know if any of the companies were the same ones stiffing landowners their rent or failing to pay property taxes.”
Minister of Municipal Affairs Dan Williams said earlier this year that the majority of approximately $250 million in oil and gas companies’ unpaid property taxes to rural municipalities is “fundamentally unrecoverable.”
The list that Meintzer obtained reveals that just eight out of 80 non-governmental participants in the MAS consultation process represented the interests of landowners and municipalities that have been stiffed by oil and gas companies.
These consist of the Rural Municipalities of Alberta, property rights lawyer Keith Wilson (whom readers might be more familiar with as an Alberta separatist leader), Alberta Municipalities, the Alberta Surface Rights Federation, the Wheatland and Area Surface Rights Society, My Landman Group, Ponoka County and Spencer Hilton Acres.
The list also includes representation from three arms-length provincial bodies, including the Land and Property Rights Tribunal and the tribunal’s predecessor, the Surface Rights Board, which are intended to mediate between the interests of the energy industry and landowners, as well as the Alberta Energy Regulator. In April 2024, Premier Smith appointed Yager to the regulator’s board.
The remaining 69 non-governmental participants consist of companies and advocacy groups representing industry’s interests, chief among them oil and gas, but also include well abandonment companies, Crown corporations with heavy investments in oil and gas, such as provincial pension fund manager AIMCo, as well as several consultancy, engineering and real estate firms.
Some of the companies that participated were invited to join consultations by industry advocacy groups, such as the Exploration and Producers Association of Canada, which had representation in each working group.
Another advocacy group, Enserva, which represents the interests of oilfield service companies, invited Winterhawk Well Abandonment to participate in one of the working groups, which were being facilitated by its former president and CEO, Yager.
The Ministry of Energy and Minerals didn’t respond to an inquiry about the working groups’ apparent lopsided composition.
In October 2026, reporter Brett McKay of the Investigative Journalism Foundation compiled a database of hundreds of oil and gas companies that the Land and Property Rights Tribunal ruled in 2025 owe at least $40,000 in delinquent rent to landowners, either as a sole operator or co-operator of a surface lease.
When the tribunal rules that a company is delinquent in paying its leases, it orders the provincial government to pay the landowner, with the company required to reimburse the provincial treasury for the full amount if it’s a sole operator or the proportion of its share in the lease if it’s a joint operator.
According to reporting from Sharon Riley in The Narwhal, the government recouped less than 1% of the $148,150,967 it covered in unpaid surface leases to landowners from 2010 to 2024.
Cross-referencing the list of MAS participants with McKay’s database shows that 11 companies that were consulted on the MAS were listed the following year as operators on lease payments that were paid by the government.
CNRL, the largest oil and gas producer in the province, had the government cover $1.3 million in lease payments which had it listed as a co-operator. The company reported $10.8 billion in profit in 2025.
A company being listed as a co-operator doesn’t necessarily mean it was the operator responsible for missing the lease payments, but the Land and Property Rights Tribunal has ruled that co-operators are jointly responsible for compensation.
Drew Yewchuk, an expert in environmental and resource law who’s working on his PhD in law at the Peter Allard School of Law in Vancouver, told The Orchard that the only reason CNRL may not have reimbursed the government is that it’s appealing a series of decisions that the company argues improperly listed it as a co-operator.
“CNRL has plenty of money. There’s no way they’re not paying,” said Yewchuk.
Other companies involved in the MAS consultations that are listed solely as co-operators of leases that the government had to pay include Cenovus ($66,420), Torxen Energy ($42,142), Whitecap Resources ($43,935), Pine Cliff Energy ($315,136), Strathcona Resources ($55,690), Ovintiv Canada ($78,630) and Tourmaline Oil ($61,320).
The government has covered $85,975 in payments for leases that name Ember Resources, a private company owned by Brookfield Asset Management, as an operator, including $37,787 for leases on which it’s listed as the sole operator.
The government paid $112,831 in rent for projects that Signalta Resources was an operator on, including $10,000 in which it was the sole operator.
One renewable energy firm was included in MAS consultations — Futera Power, a geothermal company that is a subsidiary of Razor Energy. The government has paid $724,951 in delinquent leases that name Razor as an operator, $161,331 of which named Razor as the sole operator.
The provincial treasury is going to have difficulty recouping the $218,091 in rent it paid on behalf of Forden Energy, including $89,905 in payments for which the company was listed as a sole operator. In February 2026, Forden went into receivership.
“The companies who have these wells where they’re not paying their land leases are the ones the MAS is designed to help,” Yewchuk said of their presence during consultations. “It’s for them.”
The Ministry of Red Tape Reduction and Service Alberta is responsible for recovering payments for Land and Property Rights Tribunal Rulings.
It didn’t acknowledge an inquiry about how much money it’s recovered from companies listed on the surface leases it covered in 2025.
Nor did the Ministry of Energy and Minerals respond when asked what means it has to force companies to reimburse the treasury for unpaid surface lease payments.
While they may have been vastly outnumbered during the consultation process, landowner advocates have been entirely shut out of discussions that are underway regarding MAS’s implementation.
Yewchuk said the exclusion of landowner groups is unsurprising, because the MAS’s approach towards dealing with inactive wells “was picked in advance.”
While the MAS talks about inactive wells, including the 9,258 orphan wells that are registered to bankrupt companies, its real purpose is to make struggling natural gas producers profitable, with the assumption that this would enable them to pay for restoring inactive well sites back to their original state, a process known as remediation.
These producers own many of the province’s 97,031 marginally producing wells, which are classified as producing fewer than 10 barrels of oil equivalent a day.
The MAS envisions the establishment of two “special purpose entities” — ClosureCo, which companies can pay to assume liability for their inactive or marginal wells, and HarvestCo, which extracts whatever fossil fuels remain in those wells and uses the proceeds to fund their remediation.
“The problem is that the assets aren’t profitable,” explained Yewchuk, “so the government is going to interfere with the regulatory system and the market for oil and gas to try to make these unprofitable, mostly shallow gas wells somehow more profitable by decreasing the requirements for closure, or somehow passing the closure cost onto the public.”
In a 2021 column for the website Energy Now, Yager complained of Alberta’s “increasingly strict environmental protection and reclamation regulations” putting an undue burden on industry.
“Albertans must permit the government to move past the ‘polluter pay’ mantra and deal with the issues as they exist today,” Yager wrote, referring dismissively to the legal principle enshrined in Canadian law that responsibility for environmental cleanup belongs to polluters.
Bill Heidecker of the Alberta Surface Rights Federation, who was invited to participate in the MAS consultations but not its implementation discussions, said he believes this column provided a “policy blueprint” for the MAS that reflected Yager’s “predetermined agenda.”
He told The Orchard that he sees “no indication” that the government has any interest in solving landowners’ problems with aging oil and gas infrastructure on their properties.
“The province just seems hell bent on making sure they get every molecule out of the ground that might yield a royalty,” he said. “That’s what it is. It’s all about the money for the royalties and to be damned with everybody else.”
Because landowner advocates like Heidecker used their limited presence during consultations to forcefully object to this agenda, they were shut out of the implementation phase, Yewchuk suggested.
“To have a real consultation process, you have to not have picked your outcome in advance. Otherwise, you’re going to have to kick out everyone who doesn’t like that outcome and the process is kind of fake,” said Yewchuk.
The Ministry of Energy and Minerals didn’t acknowledge a request for comment on landowner advocates’ exclusion from MAS’s implementation discussions.
Bill 43, an omnibus piece of legislation introduced in the legislature on Nov. 18, includes a provision requiring oil and gas companies to pay a security deposit upwards of $50,000 a year for a decade for each new well they drill to fund its eventual remediation.
But the Coalition for Responsible Energy says the policy does nothing to address the cost of eventually remediating the 326,061 existing wells that haven’t yet been remediated, let alone unpaid property taxes and surface leases.
Internal Alberta Energy Regulator estimates for the cost of cleaning up after the oil and gas industry in Alberta range from $88 billion to $260 billion, far higher than the public estimate of $33 billion.
The Surface Rights Federation is urging landowners to refuse to co-operate with oil and gas companies who own the mineral rights under their land, forcing them to go to costly hearings at the Land and Property Rights Tribunal until the government establishes a pathway for industry to pay the true cost of doing business.
The federation’s refusal to co-operate with industry, said Heidecker, is an act of last resort for landowners.
”We never said we’re anti-energy, but we’re definitely anti-landowners getting screwed. Full stop,” he said. “Our point is there’s got to be legitimate, enforced regulations to protect landowners and other stakeholders.”



